Dangerous Premises

Can a Contractor Be Liable for a Property Injury?

Property owners often hire third-party contractors to handle maintenance, repairs, construction, and other work on their premises. But what happens when the work creates a dangerous condition that injures someone?

In these situations, the contractor’s actions or inactions may have contributed to the injury, but the contractor may not be the only party responsible. Depending on the circumstances, both the contractor and the property owner may be held liable for an injury.

Knowing who may be held responsible for your injuries is an important step in determining your legal options and pursuing compensation for your losses.

What Is Third-Party Contractor Liability?

Sometimes called independent contractors, third-party contractors are companies or individuals hired to perform work on a property. Maintenance, repairs, construction, cleaning, landscaping, and snow and ice removal are common third-party contractor services.

If a contractor creates a hazardous condition that causes someone else an injury, they may be held liable for the resulting harm. That said, a contractor is not automatically liable for an injury just because it occurred on a property where they performed work. Liability depends on the incident’s circumstances, the contractor’s responsibilities, and whether the contractor’s actions or omissions fell below the applicable standard of care.

Contractor Liability Under BC Law

Whether or not a contractor is liable for an injury depends on whether their negligence caused or contributed to the victim’s harm. To establish negligence, the victim needs to show that the contractor:

  • Owed the injured person a duty of care
  • Failed to meet the appropriate standard of care
  • Caused or contributed to an injury that resulted in losses

BC’s Negligence Act also addresses how responsibility is divided when the fault of multiple parties contributes to an injury. If a contractor and a property owner are both found at fault, the court may apportion responsibility according to each party’s degree of fault. If the court cannot determine different degrees of fault after considering the circumstances, it must apportion responsibility equally.

This matters because an injured person may be able to pursue compensation from more than one party. Depending on the circumstances and the Act’s exceptions, parties found at fault may be jointly and severally liable for the injured person’s losses. Joint and several liability means an injured person may recover the full amount of their damages from any one of the liable parties.

A contractor’s failure to meet the terms of their agreement with a property owner does not, by itself, establish liability to someone injured on the property. The contractor’s responsibilities, the risks associated with the work, the precautions taken, and whether the contractor’s actions or omissions contributed to the injury are relevant to the claim.

When Can a Property Owner Also Be Liable?

Hiring a contractor does not automatically protect a property owner from liability if the contractor’s work causes an injury. Under BC’s Occupiers Liability Act, a property owner may avoid liability for damage caused by an independent contractor’s negligence if they took reasonable care when selecting and supervising the contractor, and it was reasonable to have the work done.

Depending on the circumstances, the property owner may also be liable. Relevant factors include:

  • Contractor selection: Whether the property owner took reasonable care to select a contractor qualified and suitable for the work.
  • Contractor supervision: Whether the property owner took reasonable care in supervising the contractor.
  • The work itself: Whether it was reasonable for the work to be undertaken.

Discuss Your Injury With Stephens & Holman

If you’ve been injured due to a contractor’s negligence on dangerous premises, you may be unsure who is responsible or how to pursue compensation. Stephens & Holman can help you understand your rights and determine what legal options may be available based on the circumstances of your injury. Contact the firm to discuss your situation with a member of our team.

Share